The magi were not three guys with trinket boxes
Asked whether the Pope's book covers the wise men, the hosts riff on how inaccurate the nativity scene is: the magi came years later in an armed caravan bearing shiploads of gifts, which is why all of Jerusalem was abuzz and why Herod gave them an audience. They compare movies' inability to capture reality, doubting the nativity, the Sermon on the Mount, or the crucifixion (the Passion of the Christ 'didn't actually go as far' as the real violence) can be filmed accurately.
More on Movies
-
Images of Jesus and crucifixion reenactments: would you play Jesus?
- Would you play a crucified Jesus in a reenactment?
A tangent on whether depicting Jesus violates the command against making images — the host notes the Last Supper is not a scriptural problem anyway, and muses on early-church icon…
From No. 536 · The Olympic Supper Club
-
Is it wrong not to dwell on crucifixion gore?
- Is it wrong not to dwell on the violent, gory details of Jesus' crucifixion?
Second 'is this wrong?' case, submitted by Ben: is it wrong that he doesn't dwell on the excruciating details of the crucifixion or find them all that important?
From No. 524 · Handshakes and Wrongness
-
The Shack: book, movie, and theological controversy
- Is it okay to read or watch The Shack?
- Is the author of The Shack a believer? Was it published by a Christian publisher?
A long discussion of The Shack prompted by its film release. One host, who listened to it on audiobook while new in the faith, says it made him think and drove him back to his Bible without replacing his theology.
From No. 312 · The Shack
-
Filtered DVDs, cursing, and Jesus Christ Superstar
- How much do you need to see a movie if you need a filtered version of it?
- Can a movie like Jesus Christ Superstar teach anything true about Jesus?
A substantive discussion: are profanity-filtering DVD players worthwhile, and 'how much do I need to see a movie if I need a filtered version of it?'