Florida pastor scandal: forgiveness versus fitness for ministry
- A pastor was caught in adultery and refuses to resign, saying God has already forgiven him — can he stay in the pulpit?
A host sets the agenda: the presidential executive order discussion and an article about a Tallahassee pastor caught in adultery who refuses to resign, saying God has already forgiven him. One host reads the article's account — Rev. O. Germaine Simmons Sr. caught in bed with parishioner Clayneisha Stevens by her husband Benjamin Stevens III, then fleeing the house naked. The hosts dissect the pastor's logic ('if I step down it presupposes I was qualified in the first place'), contrast hyper-grace with accountability, and argue that forgiveness does not automatically restore fitness to lead a congregation.
More on Accountability
-
Do accountability partners actually work?
- Do accountability partners actually do anything?
Mike raises his accountability-partners question: the standard dude-circle advice to get a buddy to hold you accountable for Bible reading, porn, church attendance, and drinking.
From No. 598 · Emphasis | Accountability, Worship and Praying with Strangers
-
Telling your spouse about past sin: pornography, the granola bar, and the Holy Spirit
- If you have repented of a sin your spouse never knew about, do you have to tell them?
The hosts work through whether a repented-of sin a spouse never knew about must be confessed: a pornography habit versus a stolen granola bar from fifteen years ago.
From No. 579 · Wanted: Paul and Hope | Paul’s Persecution of Christians and Radical Redemption
-
Feeling spiritually meh: causes, experiences, and ways through
- Have you ever felt spiritually meh, what does it feel like, and how do you get out of it?
The main discussion: what it means to feel "spiritually meh" — not rebelling against God, but not wanting to do the prayer, Bible reading, and other connecting practices you know are good.
-
What does it mean to make disciples
- What does it mean to make disciples — is it just giving information, or does it involve accountability and structure?
The hosts take up the third topic: two extremes of disciple-making. On one side, being only an information provider and leaving everything to the Spirit; on the other, running…
From No. 545 · By Invitation Only