Skip to content
Dear LFTP March 16, 2026 · 1:10:18 · 7 min

Dear LFTP: Martha, John, and Jerry

  • How should a woman in love with her ex's brother tell friends, family, and his parents?

A host reads the first Dear LFTP letter: Martha dated John for two years, then he kept living with her six months after the breakup; John is an emotionally and verbally abusive alcoholic who burned every bridge. Martha has now fallen for John's brother Jerry, and they fear his elderly parents' disapproval. The hosts advise that feelings are untrustworthy, that neither the parents nor Jerry protected her from John, and that she needs a Christian community to evaluate her choices rather than secrecy. The Secular answer agrees the couple should not hide and says Jerry must tell his mother plainly or the relationship will wither.

More on Community

Now playing
0:00 0:00