Skip to content
Dear LFTP February 9, 2015 · 50:11 · 8 min

Dear LFTP: third engagement party, gift obligatory?

  • If my friend's son gets engaged a third time and has an engagement party, am I obligated to bring a gift?

A host reads a Dear LFTP letter asking whether a gift is obligatory at a family friend's son's third engagement party, after two broken engagements kept both rounds of gifts. The hosts agree the letter-writer has given enough and that the son should stop accepting gifts; one host notes he would return the gifts himself. The discussion veers into a long bit: engagement parties 'are not a real thing,' one host is asked if Ben ever had one, and another host admits he has never heard of a toaster oven or a bread box, prompting a full explanation. The Secular answer: by now she has given enough, and the family surely will not invite the same people expecting more gifts.

More on Generosity

Now playing
0:00 0:00